6:07 PM The Bruce - 1996 -Battle of Bannockburn 1314 'line of fire' _ Bannockburn 1314 | |
Published on Mar 14, 2014 History documentary taken from the line of fire series. With expert analysis from Sandhurst Military Academys finest alongside our own author/ historian the mighty Bob Carruthers=================================================
Published on Jul 14, 2013 Released amid the hysteria after 'Braveheart', this low budget effort is a fine piece of Scottish culture but an utterly awful movie. Paradoxically, this is reasonably historically accurate but isn't a very good film, while Braveheart, though a great movie, is about as historically accurate as The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe. Still, this is worth a watch, and quite culturally relevant with an independence referendum coming in 2014 the same year as Bannockburn's 700th anniversary. Utter cringe at the spider scene, the spider/inspiration theme is a story attached to many of history's great people like Saul, Frederick the Great, The prophet Mohammed and a host of other characters throughout history - and it's very likely not to be true. One thing that gives this the edge over Braveheart is its more accurate depiction of Scottish armies at the time. We weren't tartan-clad men covered in shit with no armour and armed with farm tools, nor was our cavalry made up of tartan clad men in leather hoods armed with meat cleavers, as Braveheart suggests. Scots armies were equipped in exactly the same way as the English armies, horse and foot, Wallace and Bruce later both used to send men home if they didn't have adequate armour and weapons. The English just outnumbered us most of the time, that's all. As to this film,it's more accurate than Braveheart, but still seems very myopic from a historian's perspective, and was made by the same crowd who made the not quite as bad but equally low-budget 'Chasing The Deer' about the '45 and Culloden. Many of the actors from Chasing the Deer are in this too. for the insult to our history that was the entertaining fairy-story 'Braveheart', make this new one equally entertaining, but HISTORICALLY ACCURATE. ========================================================================================= ============================================================================
| |
|
Total comments: 0 | |